Protest Decisions

CAUTION: The New Motor Vehicle Board (Board) does not warrant the accuracy of this information. While the Board strives to maintain and provide accurate information, the data presented below was compiled over many years from many sources, thus preventing the Board from assuring the perfect accuracy of the data.

To search this list begin typing any part of the protest information that you are looking for. You can search by protest number,
case name, date, or outcome. Clearing the "Search Box" also restores the "Protest List Table" to show all protest.

QuicK Search: Clear Search Box

Protest No.

Case Name

Date

Outcome

PR-1-74

Charles H. Hornburg, Jr., Motor Cars

12/20/74

3060(T) non-renewal

Overruled

PR-2-74

Ken Collins, dba Ken Collins Buick v. American Motors Sales Corporation

3/19/75

3060(T) Sustained

PR-12-75

Ameran Enterprises, Ltd., dba Lail Bros. v. Peugeot, Inc.

5/7/75

3062(E) Overruled

PR-13-75

Novato Toyota, Inc. v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

7/10/75

3060(M) Sustained

PR-22-75

Bingham Toyota, Inc.; B.C. Bingham v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

7/14/75

3062(R)

No Jurisdiction

PR-32-75

Alexander Matzkin, AKA Al Matzkin, Hayward Motors v. Ford Motor Company

7/16/75

3060(T) Overruled

PR-35-75

PR-36-75

PR-50-75

PR-51-75

Becherer Buick, Inc. v. Buick Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

O'Donnell Buick-Opel, Inc.  v. Buick Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

Becherer Buick, Inc. v. Buick Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

O'Donnell Buick-Opel, Inc.  v. Buick Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

12/21/76

3062(E) Overruled

PR-67-75

Import Auto Sales & Services, Inc., dba Import Auto v. Renault West

9/21/76

3060(T) Overruled

PR-87-76

Jack Wall Chevrolet, Inc. v. General Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

8/10/76

3062(R) Overruled

PR-88-76

Bell Chevrolet Inc. v. Chevrolet Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

8/9/76

3062(R) Overruled

PR-92-76

Putnam Dodge v. Chrysler

12/14/76

3065 Petition Denied [sic]

PR-97-76

McKenna-Stephens Motors, Inc. dba Sun Datsun v. Nissan Motor Corporation in U.S.A.

8/18/77

3062(E) Sustained

PR-103-76

Vickers Honda, dba Vickers Honda v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

10/13/76

3062(R) Overruled

PR-105-76

J.H. Brown, dba Tricolor Motors v. Renault West, Inc.

1/27/77

3062(E) Overruled

PR-110-76

PR-111-76

Vel's Parnelli Jones Ford v. Ford Division, Ford Motor Company

Leon Ames Ford v. Ford Division, Ford Motor Company

12/14/76

3062(R) Overruled

PR-112-76

Baywood Truck and Equipment Company v. International Harvesters

2/25/77

3060(T) Overruled

PR-113-76

Import Motors, Inc. v. John Drew Motors, Inc., dba Subaru of Northern California

4/18/77

3062(E) Overruled

PR-129-77

PR-133-77

Brian Chuchua's Jeep, Inc.  v. American Motors Sales Corporation

Copeland Motors, Inc.  v. American Motors Sales Corporation

9/8/77

3062(E) Overruled

PR-130-77

PR-131-77

PR-132-77

Walker Bros. Inc.  v. American Motors Sales Corporation

Con-Ferr Inc. v. American Motors Sales Corporation

Milne Bros. Inc. v. American Motors Sales Corporation

9/14/77

3062(E) Overruled

PR-135-77

Earth Plumbing and Electric, Inc., dba J & J Cycles v. Contra Costa Cycle, Inc., dba Contra Costa Honda, and U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

5/12/77

3062(E) Overruled

PR-138-77

PR-139-77

Continental Imports v. Subaru of Southern California

Trevellyan Oldsmobile Co. v. Subaru of Southern California

2/16/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-144-77

Downtown Ford Sales v. Ford Motor Company

3/31/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-150-77

Byers-White Corporation dba Gavilan

7/17/78

3065 Protest Sustained

PR-153-77

Don Monday Buick v. American Motors Corporation and Kirby Oldsmobile-AMC

7/17/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-155-77

Albert Piano and Al Piano Datsun v. Nissan Motor Corporation

6/30/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-156-77

PR-161-77

Murphy Lincoln Mercury, A Lincoln Mercury Dealership v. Lincoln Mercury, A Division of Ford Motor Company

Bob Estes Lincoln, A Lincoln Mercury Dealership v. Lincoln Mercury, A Division of Ford Motor Company

4/18/78

3062(R) Overruled

PR-157-77

PR-158-77

Fun Bike Center, Inc. v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

George Arrues, dba Kon Tiki Motorcycles v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

4/18/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-162-78

George Arrues, dba Kon Tiki Motorcycles v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

4/18/78

3060(T) Sustained due to manufacturer=s failure to comply with 3060

PR-163-78

PR-164-78

PR-165-78

PR-166-78

Del Amo Suzuki Enterprises, Inc.  v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

Dale Brown and Dale Brown Motors v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

Ronald Ruffalo and Ruffalo Enterprises, Inc., dba Suzuki Smith v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

Joe Koons Motorcycles v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

4/18/78

3062(E) No Notice

Returned to Parties

PR-168-78

PR-169-78

PR-170-78

Foster Kelly, Inc., dba Harry D. Foster Motorcycles v. Triumph Motorcycles America, Inc.

William C. Cottom, dba Century Motorcycles v. Triumph Motorcycles America, Inc.

Norman E. Lee, dba Long Beach Triumph v. Triumph Motorcycles America, Inc.

7/12/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-171-78

Joe Barber v. Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

9/14/78

3060(T) Sustained

PR-174-78

PR-175-78

Ameran Enterprises, Ltd., dba Lail Bros.

Lail Bros. Western Ave., Inc. v. Peugot Motors of America, Inc.

9/14/78

3060(T) Overruled

PR-179-78

George Arrues, dba Kon Tiki Motorcycles v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

10/27/78

3060(T) Sustained

PR-187-78

PR-188-78

C. Bob Autrey Motors, Inc. v. Mazda Distributors Pacific, Inc.

Greenwood Pontiac Inc. v. Mazda Distributors Pacific, Inc.

11/30/78

3062(E) Overruled

PR-195-78

Campbell-Becker, Inc., dba Miracle Mazda v. Renault West, Inc.

1/25/79

3060(T) Sustained

PR-200-78

Pollard-Ravenscroft Co. v. Mercedes-Benz of North America, Inc.

6/29/79

3060(T) Sustained

PR-201-78

Pollard-Ravenscroft Co., dba Pollard-Wittman-Robb Chevrolet v. Chevrolet Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

1/22/80

3060(T) conditionally overruled; if Chevrolet fails to meet conditions, the protest is sustained

PR-212-78

PR-213-79

PR-214-78

A.P.S. Motors, Inc., dba Alex Satin Oldsmobile Mazda v. Mazda Distributors (Pacific), Inc.

Prince Motors, Inc., dba Hawthorne Mazda v. Mazda Distributors (Pacific), Inc.

2800 Wilshire Corporation, dba Santa Monica Mazda v. Mazda Distributors (Pacific), Inc.

6/8/79

3062(E) Overruled

PR-216-79

PR-217-79

PR-218-79

PR-219-79

PR-220-79

PR-221-79

Sherman Oaks Cycles Inc. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Kolbe Cycle Sales Inc. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Kolbe Cycle Sales Inc. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Allyn Schultz dba Allyn's San Fernando Honda-Kawasaki v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Bill Robertson & Sons, Inc., dba Honda of North Hollywood v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Bill Robertson & Sons, Inc. dba Honda of Burbank v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

5/9/79

3062(R)

No Jurisdiction

PR-227-79

PR-228-79

PR-229-79

Nowling's Oldsmobile, Inc. v. Oldsmobile Division of General Motors Corporation

Harris Oldsmobile, Inc. v. Oldsmobile Division of General Motors Corporation

Hansel Oldsmobile, Inc. v. Oldsmobile Division of General Motors Corporation

7/29/79

3062(R) Overruled

PR-234-79

Marquis Motors, Inc.  v. Toyota Motors Distributors, Inc.

1/11/80

3062(E) Sustained

PR-239-79

Southland Cycle Center, Inc. v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

9/25/79

3062(R) Sustained

PR-242-79

Joe Barton, Sam Tiefer, Three Star Suzuki Sport Cycles v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

1/22/80

3062(E) Overruled

PR-245-79

PR-246-79

Auto Trends Inc. v. Peugeot Motors of America, Inc.

Santa Monica Import Motors v. Peugeot Motors of America, Inc.

2/22/80

3062(E) Overruled

PR-257-79

Thur Imports Inc. v. Fiat Motors of North America, Inc.

1/22/80

3062(R) Overruled

PR-260-79

Pasadena Kawasaki, Inc. v. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

5/13/80

3060(T) Overruled

PR-262-79

Team Maybe Manana, Ltd., dba Steve's Bultaco Sales v. Bultaco International, Ltd.

2/22/80

3062(E)

No Jurisdiction

PR-263-80

PR-264-80

PR-265-80

Allec Bros. Yamaha v. Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

Anaheim Motorcycles Inc. v. Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

Orange County Cycle v. Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

12/17/80

3062(E) Sustained

PR-271-80

49er Chevrolet v. Chevrolet Motors Division, General Motors Corporation

1/28/81

3060(T) non-renewal Sustained

PR-276-80

S.O. McDonald, S.O. McDonald Enterprises, Inc. dba Royal Volvo/Subaru v. Volvo of America Corporation

10/7/80

3062(E) Overruled

PR-278-80

Friendly Motors, Inc. v. John Drew Motors, Inc., dba Subaru of Northern California

1/28/81

no jurisdiction because protest was untimely

PR-283-80

PR-286-80

Trenfel Motors, Inc., dba Toyota El Cajon v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

Rose Automotive Services, Inc. dba John A Rose Imports v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

12/17/80

3062(R) Overruled

PR-287-80

Sportmotive Corp., dba Cycle Sports v. BMW of North America, Inc., BMW Munich, Butler & Smith, Inc.

4/16/81

3060(T) Sustained

PR-314-81

PR-315-81

PR-316-81

PR-317-81

PR-318-81

D. Longo, Inc., dba Longo Toyota v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.

Rogers Toyota, Inc.  v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A. , Inc.

Mel & Mac Toyota Inc. dba Toyota of Whittier v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A. , Inc.

West Covina Toyota Inc. dba West Covina Toyota  v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.

Fairway Toyota, Inc. v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A. , Inc.

8/21/81

3062(E) Overruled

PR-324-81

PR-325-81

PR-326-81

PR-328-81

Rice Motor Co. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Le Bard & Underwood, Inc. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Rice Motor Co., dba Honda of West Covina v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

10/2/81

3062(E) Sustained

PR-329-81

Gary & Orie Cole, Alvin & Ronald Francis; Cole Bros. M/C Sales, Inc. v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

10/2/81

3062(E) Overruled

PR-336-81

Vespa at the Beaches v. Vespa of America Corporation

10/2/81

3062(R) Overruled

PR-338-81

Shepherd Pontiac, Inc. v. Pontiac Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

12/11/81

3062(E) Overruled

PR-339-81

Eugene John Buonaccorsi dba Corky Motors v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

7/14/82

3060(T) Sustained

PR-340-81

PR-350-81

Pierotti Motors, Inc., dba Pierotti Fremont Imports v. Nissan Motor Corporation in U.S.A.

Pierotti Motors, Inc., dba Pierotti Fremont Imports v. Nissan Motor Corporation in U.S.A.

12/11/81

3062(R) Overruled

PR-343-81

Downtown L.A. Imports, Inc. v. Fiat Motors of North America, Inc.

6/4/82

3060(T) Overruled

PR-344-81

PR-345-81

PR-346-81

Redlandsrider, Inc. dba Huntington Honda v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Tri City Cycle Center, Inc. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

Honda West  v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

3/2/81

3062(R) Overruled

PR-348-81

49er Chevrolet v. Chevrolet Motor Division, General Motors Corporation

12/11/81

3060(T) non-renewal Overruled

PR-361-81

Lloyd A. Wise Inc. v. GMC Truck and Coach Division of General Motors Corporation

10/25/82

3062(E) Overruled

PR-371-81

Len Sheridan, Inc. dba Len Sheridan Toyota v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

9/21/82

3062(R) Overruled

PR-386-82

Hal Watkins Chevrolet, Inc., dba Hal Watkins BMW v. BMW of North America, Inc.

1/12/83

3062(E) Sustained

PR-390-82

Nuvo, Inc., dba Hyde Park Motors v. BMW of North America, Inc.

9/21/82

3060(T) protestant failed to appear at hearing

PR-403-82

DBD Datsun, Inc., dba Dick Barbour Datsun v. Nissan Motor Corporation in U.S.A.

1/12/83

3062(R) Overruled

PR-420-82

PR-421-82

Anaheim Suzuki, Inc. v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

Irv Seaver Motorcycles, Inc. v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

4/6/83

3062(E) Sustained

PR-431-82

Daly City Datsun, Inc. v. Nissan Motor Corporation in U.S.A.

4/6/83

3062(R) Overruled

PR-443-83

Rice Motor Company dba Honda of West Covina v. American Honda Motor Company

10/18/83

3060(T) Overruled [alleged de facto termination if Honda does not approve relocation]

PR-448-83

University Ford Chrysler Plymouth v. Chrysler Corporation

10/18/83

3060(T) Conditionally sustained

PR-448-83

DECISION AFTER REMAND

University Ford Chrysler Plymouth v. Chrysler Corporation

9/29/87

[unsigned]

3060(T) Conditionally sustained [Proposed Decision after Remand]

PR-467-83

PR-468-83

PR-471-83

PR-472-83

PR-473-83

PR-474-83

PR-477-83

PR-478-83

PR-486-83

PR-487-83

Sports Cycle Center, Inc., dba Bill Krause Sports Cycle,

Ted Evans Motorcycle Sales & Service,

C & G Technology Company, Inc., dba Buena Park Yamaha,

Long Beach Yamaha,

Palm Springs Yamaha,

v.

Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

6/8/84

3060(M) Protestants are entitled to sell Yamaha RIVAs.

PR-481-83 Sec.1

PR-481-83 Sec.2

Hensley-Anderson Ford v. Ford

7/20/84

3065 Protest Sustained

PR-498-83

PR-506-83

Champion Honda vs. Yamaha

9/4/85

3062(E) Overruled

PR-499-83

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury, Inc., dba Ray Fladeboe Isuzu v. American Isuzu Motors, Inc.

9/7/84

3060(T) Sustained

PR-512-84

British Motors of Monterey, Inc. v. Maserati Import Company

7/20/84

3060(T) non-renewal Sustained

PR-699-84

PR-700-84

Honda Del Rey v. American Honda

Bill Kraus Sports Cycle v. American Honda

2/8/85

3062(E) Overruled

PR-712-84

P-145-87

Auto Trends, Inc. v. Jaguar Cars, Inc., et al.

3/29/91

3060(T) non-renewal Protest is overruled; relief sought in petition is denied

PR-713-84

P-147-87

P-166-88 through

P-173-88

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury, Inc., dba Ray Fladeboe British Motor Cars v. Jaguar Cars, Inc., et al.

3/29/91

3060(T) non-renewal protest is overruled; relief sough by the petitions is denied

PR-727-85

Alan Magnon Subaru v. Subaru

6/26/85

3062(E) Overruled

PR-739-85

Arvil Sparks Sales v. Kawasaki

11/22/85

3062(E) Overruled

PR-814-86

Vespa of San Diego v. Yamaha

6/19/87

3062(E) Sustained

PR-815-86

Vespa of San Diego v. Yamaha

6/19/87

3062(E) Overruled

PR-839-86

W. Covina Mitsubishi v. Mitsubishi

4/3/87

3062(E) Overruled

PR-864-87

Murray's Truck Service, Inc. v. Iveco Trucks of North America, Inc.

9/29/87

3060(T) Overruled

PR-871-87

P-146-87

Brian Chuchusa's Jeep, dba Brian Chuchusa's Four Wheel Drive Center v. American Motor Sales Corporation

9/29/87

(3060T) protest overruled but termination conditionally stayed; Petition decision is not signed in file cabinet

PR-874-87

PR-875-87

Harbor City Enterprises, Inc. dba Harbor City Harley v. Harley-Davidson

Harley-Davidson of Westminister, Inc. v. Harley-Davidson

8/29/88

Protest Overruled

PR-883-87

Stevens Pontiac v. Pontiac/GM

9-29-87

3062(E) Overruled

PR-916-87

SBD, Inc., dba Orange County Suzuki v. U.S. Suzuki Motor Corporation

5/18/88

3060(T) Sustained

PR-933-87

Stevens Creek European, Inc., Philip Beitpolice, dba Stevens Creek Lamborghini-Lotus v. Chrysler Motor Corporation; Nuova Automobile Ferriccio Lamborghini s.p.a.

11/15/88

3060(T) protest is dismissed with prejudice because Board lacks jurisdiction (protestant is not a franchisee)

PR-973-88

Ferrari of Sacramento, Inc. v. Ferrari North America

2/28/91

3060(T) Overruled

PR-976-88

Tara Motors, dba Toyota of El Cajon v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.; Lorelei M. Trenfel, Interested Individual

6/22/89

3060(T) protest overruled but termination conditionally sustained

PR-1003-88

P-177-88

Michael Imports, Inc., dba Van Ness Hyundai v. Hyundai Motor America

7/11/90

(3060T) Van Ness violated the terms of stipulated decision; termination permitted

PR-1004-88

P-179-88

(unreasonable denial to request for relocation)

D.C. Terry Buick, Inc. v. Buick Motor Division, General Motors Corporation, et al.

6/22/89

3060(T) Sustained; Board did not adopt portion of decision pertaining to petition

PR-1022-89

PR-1023-89

La Mesa Dodge v. Chrysler

Kearny Mesa Dodge v. Chrysler

7/20/90

3062(E) Sustained

PR-1101-89

Thomas Cadillac, Inc. v. Range Rover of North America, Inc.

12/15/89

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1117-89

PR-1118-89

McClellan Buick v. Buick

Seaside Buick v. Buick

4/3/90

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1124-89

Buena Park Hyundai v. Hyundai

4/3/90

3062(E) Sustained

PR-1135-89

PR-1136-89

Walker Buerge Ford v. Ford

Santa Monica Ford v. Ford

10/26/90

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1158-90

Person Olds v. Olds/GM

9/21/90

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1168-90

Allen Olds-GMC v. GMC Truck

10/30/90

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1189-90

DECISION AFTER REMAND

Toyota of Visalia, Inc. v. Toyota Motor Distributors, Inc.

1/11/93

3060(T) Overruled Proposed Decision After Remand

PR-1208-90

PR-1209-90

PR-1210-90

MacPherson Chevrolet

Guaranty Chevrolet

Selman Chevrolet vs. Chevrolet/GM

10/24/91

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1223-91

Del Amo Suzuki v. American Suzuki

4/8/92

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1241-91

Jim Lynch Cadillac, Inc. v. General Motors Corporation, Cadillac Motor Car Division

7/17/92

3060(T) Overruled

P-233-92

PR-1254-92

Sec. 1, Sec. 2

(3065)

Mathew Zaheri Corporation, dba Hayward Mitsubishi and Mathew Zaheri v. Mitsubishi Motor Sales of America, Inc.

9/16/94

Relief sought by the Protest and Petition is denied

PR-1380-93

Gunderson-Ihle Chevrolet vs. General Motors Corporation, Chevrolet Motor Division

9/12/95

3062(R) Overruled

PR-1405-94

PR-1494-95

PR-1495-95

Reliable Pontiac, et al vs. Pontiac Division, et al.

5/21/97

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1407-94

Sunnyday Chevrolet, Inc. v. General Motors Corporation, et al

1/25/95

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1408-94

LAX Mack Mid-Liner Sales & Service, Inc. v. Mack Trucks, Inc.

8/21/97

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1417-94

Ed-West Company, dba Costa Mesa Honda v. American Honda Motor Company, Inc.

10/13/94

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1421-94

Don Lucas International, Inc., dba Stevens Creek BMW Motorsports vs. BMW of North America, Inc.

12/27/94

3062(R) Overruled

PR-1462-95

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury v. Ford Motor Company, Lincoln-Mercury Division

6/11/96

3060(T) Sustained

PR-1462-95

DECISION AFTER REMAND

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury v. Ford Motor Company, Lincoln-Mercury Division

7/17/97

3060(T) Sustained Proposed Decision After Remand (by Sacramento County Superior Court)

PR-1501-95

Irvine Central Motors Inc., a California corporation, dba Irvine Mazda vs. Mazda Motor of America, Inc.

10/16/96

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1501-95

(After Remand)

Irvine Central Motors, Inc. Dba Irvine Mazda vs. Mazda Motor of America

7/9/97

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1511-96

Klee Story, Inc. (Honda, Kawasaki, Polaris of Santa Monica) vs. American Honda Motor Co., Inc. and DOES 1-20, Inclusive

12/11/96

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1517-96

PR-1522-96

Coast Motors, Inc., dba Rancho Oldsmobile/Saab/ Lotus v. Saab Cars USA, Inc.

Coast Motors, Inc., dba Rancho Oldsmobile/Saab/ Lotus v. Oldsmobile Division, General Motors Corporation

12/13/96

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1530-96

Hardin Oldsmobile-GMC Truck vs. General Motors Corporation, GMC Truck Division

8/21/97

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1584-97

PR-1585-97

PR-1586-97

Colonial Dodge, La Mesa Dodge World, Inc.,dba Carl Burger=s Dodge World, Kearney Mesa Dodge vs. Chrysler Corporation, a Delaware corporation

12/15/98

3062(E) Overruled

PR-1624-98

Quaid Imports, Inc. dba Quaid Nissan v. Nissan Motor Corporation, U.S.A.

12/15/98

3062(E) Sustained

PR-1633-98

Saba A. Saba, SPD Partners, Inc. and Honda Kawasaki Sportcenter vs. Kawasaki Motors Corporation, U.S.A.

2/18/00

6/26/01

3060(T) Conditionally Sustained

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1702-00

Sacramento Valley Ford Truck Sales, Inc., v. Sterling Truck Corporation, a corporation, a subsidiary of Freightliner Corporation, a DaimlerChrysler Company

9/10/02

3060(T) Sustained

PR-1765-01

Corning Truck & Radiator Service, Inc. v. International Truck & Engine Corporation

6/6/02

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1798-02

Sec.1

Sec. 2

Daugherty Lincoln Mercury v. Ford Motor Company, Lincoln Mercury Division

4/24/03

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1819-02

MICHAEL CADILLAC, INC. dba MICHAEL VOLKSWAGEN v. VOLKSWAGEN OF AMERICA, INC.

6/7/03

3062(E)

Overruled

PR-1835-02

LONG BEACH HONDA v. AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR COMPANY

9/2/03

3062(R)

Overruled

PR-1844-03

FREMONT AUTOMOBILE DEALERSHIP, LLC dba FREMONT TOYOTA v. TOYOTA MOTOR SALES, U.S.A. , INC.

4/22/04

3062(R)

Overruled

PR-1859-03

S & C Motors, Inc. dba S & C Kia v. Kia Motors America, Inc.

9/21/05

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1869-03

PR-1870-03

PR-1871-03

PR-1872-03

FOX HILLS AUTO, INC., doing business as AIRPORT MARINA FORD, WALKER MOTOR CO., d/b/a BUERGE FORD, CRENSHAW MOTORS, INC., d/b/a CRENSHAW FORD, FORD OF SANTA MONICA, INC., d/b/a SANTA MONICA FORD v.  FORD MOTOR COMPANY

11/4/04

3062(E)

Sustained

PR-1880-03

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury, Inc. v. American Isuzu Motors, Inc.

9/30/04

3065.1 protest overruled

PR-1881-03

Ray Fladeboe Lincoln-Mercury, Inc. v. American Isuzu Motors, Inc.

9/30/04

3065 Protest Overruled

PR-1894-04

S & C Motors, Inc. dba S & C Kia v. Kia Motors America, Inc.

4/5/06

3065.1 Decision sustaining protest was set aside and protest was dismissed

PR-1945-05

PH Automotive Holding Corporation dba Pacific Honda v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

1/23/06

3062(E)

Overruled

1/26/06 Board remand to ALJ.

PR-1945-05

PH Automotive Holding Corporation dba Pacific Honda v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.

6/16/06

3062(E)

Overruled

Proposed Decision After Remand

PR-1965-05

Thompson's Auto & Truck Center, Inc., dba Thompson's Chrysler-Jeep v. DaimlerChrysler Motors Company, LLC

6/16/06

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1969-05

Frontier Infiniti v. Nissan North America, Inc., Infiniti Division

10/17/06

3062(E)

Overruled

PR-1972-05

Forty-Niner Sierra Resources, Inc. v. Subaru of America

11/15/07

3060(T) Overruled

Proposed Decision After Remand

PR-1977-05

Serpa Automotive Group Inc. v. Volkswagen of America Inc.

9/28/06

3060(T) Overruled

PR-1978-05

Pomona Valley Kawasaki/KTM v. KTM North

9/28/06

3060(T) Overruled

PR-2036-07

PR-2074-07

Manteca Trailer and Camper Inc. dba RVs of Sacramento v. Home and Park Motorhomes Roadtrek

Manteca Trailer And Camper, Inc.,

dba Brawley's RV v. Home and Park Motorhomes Roadtrek

12/13/07

3070(T) Sustained

PR-2042-07

Bob Lewis Volkswagen dba Bob Lewis Suzuki v. American Suzuki Motor Corp.

10/29/10

3065.1 overruled

PR-2048-07

Walker Management, Inc., dba Good Times Kawasaki Suzuki Ducati v. Ducati North America, Inc.

6/26/08

3062(E)

Overruled

Proposed Decision Following Remand

PR-2096-07

Carlsen Subaru v. Subaru of America, Inc.

3/24/09

3062(R)

Overruled

Proposed Decision After Remand

PR-2146-09

Walter Timmons Enterprises Inc., dba Timmons Volkswagen v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.

12/10/09

3062(R)

Sustained

PR-2153-09

RV Ready v. Gulf Stream Coach, Inc.

5/5/10

3076 Overruled but dealer entitled to $30,000

PR-2199-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

10/17/12

3/15/17

3070(M) sustained

Set aside and vacaded pending remand

PR-2201-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

10/17/12

3/15/17

3070(M) sustained

Set aside and vacaded pending remand

PR-2205-10

PR-2211-10, and

PR-2212-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

8/23/12

3076 sustained

PR-2206-10

PR-2208-10, and

PR-2209-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

8/23/12

3075 sustained

PR-2213-10

West Covina Motors, Inc. dba Clippinger Chevrolet v. General Motors, LLC

8/22/12

3060(T) Conditionally sustained  termination of franchise pending the occurrence of one of two alternatives; otherwise franchise terminates on     11-13-12.

PR-2233-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

8/23/12

3072(E) sustained

PR-2244-10

Mega RV Corp. dba McMahon's RV v. Roadtrek Motorhomes, Inc.

8/23/12

3070(T) overruled

PR-2263-10

PR-2264-10

Santa Monica Group, Inc. v. General Motors LLC

9/27/11

3060(T) Santa Monica Group violated the order adopting the stipulated decision so its Buick and Chevrolet franchises were voluntarily terminated

PR-2265-10

Shayco, Inc. dba Ontario Volkswagen v. Volkswagen of America, Inc.

12/13/11

Board Decision Vacated

PR-2299-11

Laidlaw's Harley-Davidson Sales, Inc. dba Laidlaw's Harley-Davidson v. Harley-Davidson Motor Company

5/24/12

3060(T) conditionally sustained

PR-2310-11

Riverside Motorcycle, Inc. dba Skip Fordyce Harley-Davidson v. Harley-Davidson Motor Company

8/22/12

3060(T) conditionally sustained

PR-2328-12
PR2333-12
Burbank Kawasaki, Inc. v. Kawasaki Motors Corp., U.S.A. 11/12/13 3060(T) conditionally sustained
PR-2339-12
PR-2340-12
PR-2341-12

Aldon, Inc. dba Carson Toyota v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.; H.T.L. Automotive Inc., dba Hooman Toyota of Long Beach and Hooman Scion of Long Beach (Intervenor)

Aldon, Inc. dba Carson Scion v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.; H.T.L. Automotive Inc., dba Hooman Toyota of Long Beach and Hooman Scion of Long Beach (Intervenor)

Cabe Brothers dba Cabe Toyota and Cabe Scion v. Touota Motors Sales, U.S.A., Inc.; H.T.L. Automotive Inc., dba Hooman Toyota of Long Beach and Hooman Scion of Long Beach (Intervenor)

11/12/13

3062(R)
Overruled

PR-2369-13
PR-2370-13
McConnell Chevrolet Buick, Inc. v. General Motors, LLC 11/12/13 3060(T)
Overruled
PR-2361-13 Guarantee Fork Lift, Inc. dba GLF, Inc. v. Capacity of Texas, Inc. 4/28/14


1/18/17
3060(T)
Sustained

3060(T)
Overruled
PR-2358-13 Santa Cruz Nissan, Inc., dba Santa Cruz Nissan v. Nissan North America, Inc. 9/17/14 3060(T)
Conditionally sustained
PR-2429-15
PR-2430-15
PR-2431-15
PR-2432-15
HC Automotive, Inc., dba Hooman
Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram v. Fiat
Chrysler Automobiles
9/13/16 3065.1 Overruled
PR-2435-15
PR-2436-15
Dependable Dodge, Inc. v. Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, Inc. 3/15/17 3060(T) Sustained
PR-2463-17 California New Car Dealers Association v. Jaguar Land Rover North America 11/7/17 3085 Sustained in part/overruled in part